Tuesday, June 15, 2010

Parliament to debate coal power-Malaysiakini

Photo taken from Malaysia Kini

Joseph Sipalan
Jun 15, 10
2:27pm

(Taken from Malaysia Kini, to subscribe to Malaysia Kini, go to: www.malaysiakini.com)

Original Malaysia Kini article link

Anti-coal power coalition Green Surf has made inroads into Parliament, persuading speaker Pandikar Amin Mulia to set aside time to debate the controversial coal-powered plant in Sabah.

Pandikar (right) gave his word that MPs from both sides of the divide will get 30 minutes each to debate the issue, though the issue is only expected to be raised when debate ends on the 10th Malaysia Plan.

The group spoke to Pandikar in his chambers today, at a meeting arranged by Sapp's Tawau MP Chua Soon Bui.

Also present were her Sapp colleague and Sepanggar MP Eric Majimbun, Putatan MP Marcus Mojigoh of Sabah-based BN party Upko, DAP's Kota Kinabalu MP Hiew King Chew and Segambut MP Lim Lip Eng, and PKR's Lembah Pantai MP Nurul Izzah Anwar.

“All I can do as speaker is to allow for this issue to be debated. Thirty minutes is a lot of time, and I hope the MPs who will speak on the issue will keep their focus on it,” Pandikar said told the group.

He advised the coalition to continue pushing its case through the relevant government channels, stressing that they should emphasise facts and figures and avoid using politically-tinged arguments.

At a press conference later, Green Surf member Cynthia Ong said the group acknowledges the need for more power in Sabah, but said the state and federal governments should look at the many renewable energy options available to the state.

“Our coalition commissioned a report from UC Berkley California, by one of the world's leading alternative energy experts. We have all the resources necessary to go renewable in Sabah... more than many places in the world,” she said.

“Sabah has been a regional leader in conservation, and we're trying to protect that. One of our biggest resources is eco-tourism, which is also something we're trying to protect.”

At the press conference, Nurul Izzah pointed out that the issue is one of the few that cuts across political lines, as it focuses on conserving a natural heritage that is important not only to Sabah but the nation.

Memo submitted

Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Mohd Nazri Abdul Aziz accepted a memorandum from the group on behalf of premier Najib Abdul Razak, and promised to raise the issue at the next cabinet meeting.

“I understand your sentiments and, as I said, I promise to bring this matter up and hope that something can be done. I also believe the reefs, the environment, once destroyed is lost forever,” he said.

We don't want to lose this heritage which belongs to the people of Malaysia.”

Copies of the memorandum were also presented to Natural Resource and Environment Minister Douglas Uggah Embas, the speaker and several Sabah MPs.

Letter from the WORLD to Malaysian Prime Minister!

Send letters from your part of the world to the Malaysian Prime Minister letting him know you too are concerned about the coal fired power plant in Sabah, North Borneo, Malaysia.

Link here for a link to a downloadable one at : Letter to PM

Or cut and paste below.

Thanks all.

Green SURF


YAB Datuk Seri Mohd. Najib bin Tun Haji Abdul Razak
Office of The Prime Minister
Main Block, Perdana Putra Building
Federal Government Administrative Centre
62502 Putrajaya,
MALAYSIA

Tel : 603-8888 8000
Fax : 603-8888 3444
Email: najib@1malaysia.com.my

(Date)

A LETTER FROM THE WORLD TO MALAYSIA

Dear Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak, Prime Minister of Malaysia,
We applaud your Copenhagen pledge to reduce Malaysia’s carbon emission intensity by up to 40% by 2020 and admire your leadership in establishing the Coral Triangle Initiative to protect 1.6 billion acres of some of the world’s richest marine resources.

Your recent acknowledgment that Malaysia’s current fuel mix for power generation is skewed too much in favor of natural gas and coal and your commitment to exploring alternative energy sources is commendable. Your leadership is setting an example for the rest of the world.

We are therefore shocked by your support for plans to build a 300MW coal-fired power plant in Lahad Datu, on the Malaysian edge of the Sulu-Sulawesi Marine Ecoregion, the apex of the Coral Triangle. As you know, this location is ecologically unique, home to 75% of all known coral species and more than half of the world’s reefs, vulnerable coastal communities, and neighbor to some of Sabah’s most precious ecosystems. Lahad Datu is a gateway to both the Tabin Wildlife Reserve, which serves as an oasis for large numbers of animals (some endangered), and to Danum Valley, largely recognized as one of the world’s most complex ecosystems. The Sabah government has begun the process to nominate neighboring Maliau Basin, one of Borneo’s most pristine and important habitats, as a World Heritage Site.

A coal-fired power plant in this area would be catastrophic for the most vulnerable and precious of our ecosystems, and any new coal plant in Malaysia will undoubtedly undercut your efforts to build a low carbon economy. In every case to date, coal has proven effective at supplying cheap energy, but at the expense of human health and longevity, biodiversity and power diversification. And if this coal-fired power plant is built, we know that more will follow and the once pristine wilderness and coral reefs will be subject to degradation and loss.

Malaysia, with its abundant resources, is in a unique position to spearhead the use of clean energy. You recently asked, “are there alternatives not yet considered, that could firmly establish Malaysia as a global green revolution leader?” The study Meeting energy demand in a developing economy without damaging the environment - a case study in Sabah, Malaysia, from technical, environmental and economic perspectives, conducted by Malaysian scientists at the Tunku Abdul Rahman University and accepted for publication by the journal Energy Policy, found that Sabah’s energy needs may be met with alternative renewable energy options at a competitive price, with less environmental impact, much lower emission of greenhouse gases, and better fuel security for Malaysia. Similarly, the study Clean Energy Options for Sabah presented in March 2010 by some of the world’s leading energy experts gives detailed recommendations on how to meet Sabah’s energy needs without the construction of the coal-fired power plant. It puzzles us as to why these reports and the alternatives they recommend have not been taken seriously. Malaysia could lead the world in a new era of renewable energy development if investors believe that you are serious in your commitment. We worry that your exemplary stance taken at Copenhagen will be seen as ‘hot air’ if the coal-fired power plant is approved, and drive away potential investment. Adding a 300 MW coal-fired power plant in Sabah (carbonizing strongly one state, and one that actually has the resource mix to decarbonize) makes a 40% national cut in carbon emission intensity impossible without cuts in other areas nationally that are simply not seen as possible.

By your pledge we know that Malaysia has a strong intention in solving the climate problem. A firm choice to halt building of coal-fired power plants is a major step towards a solution of the global warming problem. If Malaysia halted construction of this coal-fired power plant it could be a tipping point for the region and the world. There is still time to find that tipping point, but just barely. We hope that you will give these considerations your attention in setting your national policies. You have the potential to influence our joint futures on the planet.

Datuk Seri Najib, we cannot avert our eyes from the basic fossil fuel facts, or the consequences for life on our planet of ignoring these scientific facts. If we continue to build coal-fired power plants, and in ecologically sensitive areas such as Sabah, we will lock in future climate disasters associated with passing climate-tipping points. We must solve the coal problem now.

Though it is the responsibility of all of us to maintain the balance that exists on our planet, you, as Prime Minister, are in the privileged and hugely responsible position of guiding your country’s decisions. As a steward of your country and of this earth, we ask you to decide wisely for our children and for our children’s children.

The opportunity exists now for you to be a champion for Malaysia and for the world - to move forward into a clean energy future. The developing world does not need to repeat the damaging mistakes of the developed world, which now requires immense resources to repair; the developing world can lead the way for the world into the 21st century and beyond, and Malaysia has strong potential to blaze that trail. Tell us what you need to build Malaysia’s clean energy economy and we will stand beside you.

Yours sincerely,



Name
Organization
Country

Sunday, May 23, 2010

2 Members of Green SURF Comments to PM Published in Mainstream Media!!!

An article carried by the News Straits Times with the Prime Minister discussing energy options for Malaysia mentions Green SURF supporters!

Time to keep the PRESSURE up WRITE to the PM TODAY!!

Click link here : http://bit.ly/91Fzmp

Government to explore all energy options

2010/05/21
By Anis Ibrahim
news@nstp.com.my
single
KUALA LUMPUR: All options for renewable electricity generation, from biomass to wind, will be explored before a decision is made, said Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak.

In his latest posting on his 1Malaysia blog, Najib said both the rakyat and experts would be consulted, consistent with his policy of public engagement.

"Our energy future is an important discussion, and I would like that you continue to share questions and concerns with Energy, Green Technology and Water Minister (Datuk Seri) Peter Chin Fah Kui and I. With your help, I'm confident that we can build a cleaner, greener Malaysia."


Najib said the public poll on his earlier blog entry on renewable energy options showed that 59 per cent of respondents were in favour of solar energy, with nuclear in second place at 23 per cent.

Third and fourth spots went to biomass and wind respectively.

He, however, added that further consultation was necessary due to the discrepancy in the poll results and the comments left by readers.


"At the time of writing, nuclear energy accounted for more than two-thirds of submissions, with those in favour and those against in equal numbers. Solar energy was the second most popular comment category, with biomass and wind in third and fourth positions.

"All this suggests to me that feelings on which energy source is best are mixed overall and confirms that we have further to go before implementing a decision on nuclear energy.

"All options for electricity generation, from biomass to wind, will be explored. We will consult experts and we will consult the rakyat, as there must be public engagement."


A Malaysian Renewable Energy Bill, he added, was being drafted by the Ministry of Energy, Green Technology and Water for tabling before Parliament this year.

"If we get it right, at least 52,000 jobs can be created and approximately RM70 billion worth of businesses will be generated by the renewable energy sector by 2020, according to experts."

In response, reader 'feistgeist' posted: "If this is the case PM, I really really hope that you will consider using Sabah as a platform for green technology in Malaysia. Don't build the coal plant!," he said, referring to the proposal for Tenaga Nasional Berhad to build a coal-fired plant in Sabah.

"Please understand that our natural heritage means a great deal to the Sabahan people. Do not go back on your vows at the Copenhagen Environmental Summit or the Indonesian Coral Triangle Summit. We need a leader we can trust to push this nation forward. Please be that leader for us," he added.

Another reader, 'Alex Siah' was of the view that with proper planning, progress and building of the Bakun Dam in Sarawak would be the best option available.

"Hydroelectricity is clean and recyclable with best economic sense...solar energy is a good choice too, but very capital intensive, while nuclear power is not a wise proposal due to potential pollution and non-recyclable and radioactive materials that are harmful."

'Ilann' from Sabah also asked that the coal-fired power plant plan be dropped.

"Awesome! Great news Boss! Am very sincerely happy to hear that a Malaysian Renewable Energy Bill is being drafted for this year. This IS the way forward! Please though, I implore you, please drop the coal-fired power plant that TNB is pushing on Sabah. It will jeopardise your Copenhagen commitments to cut carbon emissions by 40 per cent making that great goal almost impossible to achieve," he said.

The reader added that since Sabah had the largest oil palm planted landmass in the country, Sabahans wanted to utilise biomass and geothermal energy in Tawau.

"Please also get TNB to FIX THE GRID in Sabah -- it's still not complete. The Southern Grid has never been built. This is needed to stablise the East-West Grid. Thank you."



Read more: Government to explore all energy options http://www.nst.com.my/nst/articles/04aii/Article#ixzz0ogCRHBSF